Journal for Policy & Market Research

The Global Landscape of Direct Sales: Strategic Archetypes, Economic Volatility, and the Digital Paradigm Shift of 2026

The global direct selling industry represents a sophisticated and resilient segment of the broader retail economy, characterized by a zero-channel distribution model that facilitates direct engagement between a brand and its end-users.[1, 2] As of 2024 and 2025, the sector is navigating a transformative era defined by the stabilization of retail volumes following post-pandemic fluctuations, an aggressive regulatory pivot by agencies such as the United States Federal Trade Commission (FTC), and the rapid integration of artificial intelligence into social selling ecosystems.[3, 4, 5] Direct sales, historically rooted in personal relationships and face-to-face demonstrations, has increasingly morphed into a digital-first environment where social commerce (S-commerce) and the gig economy serve as both catalysts for innovation and existential threats to traditional structures.[6, 7, 8]

Theoretical Foundations of the Direct Sales Model

In the architectural framework of modern commerce, direct selling is fundamentally distinguished by the circumvention of traditional retail intermediaries such as wholesalers and third-party retailers.[2, 9] This “zero-channel” sales approach allows companies to maintain total control over their brand image, pricing strategies, and the overall customer experience.[1, 10] Unlike the indirect model, where products may move through a manufacturer, a wholesaler, and a retailer—a two-level channel—direct sales involves a single point of contact between the brand representative and the consumer.[1]

The model’s utility is often predicated on the necessity of product demonstration and education. Products sold through direct channels are frequently proprietary or specialized, requiring a level of personalized service and tailored solutions that traditional shelf-space retail cannot provide.[2, 10] This personalized approach enables businesses to cultivate deeper relationships with their audience, garner direct customer feedback, and gather valuable data for marketing databases—data that is often lost when selling through third-party retailers.[1, 10]

Structural Variations: Single-Level, Multi-Level, and D2C

The direct selling industry is not monolithic but is instead composed of several distinct structural archetypes that dictate how products are distributed and how the salesforce is incentivized.

Structural ModelCore MechanismCompensation LogicPrimary Channels
Direct-to-Consumer (D2C)Brand sells directly via its own website or physical stores.[1]No independent salesforce; revenue retained by brand.E-commerce, brand boutiques, pop-up stores.[10]
Single-Level Marketing (SLM)Individual representatives act as distributors.[1]Commissions earned solely on personal sales generated.[2]Door-to-door, catalogs, personal networking.[2]
Multi-Level Marketing (MLM)Hierarchy of independent distributors (upline/downline).[11]Commissions on personal sales plus overrides on downline sales.[11, 12]Social media, home parties, networking groups.[2, 13]
Party PlanSales generated through organized social gatherings.[2]Personal sales commission plus host rewards and incentives.[2]In-home demonstrations, virtual parties.[9]

The single-level model focuses primarily on the transactional relationship between the seller and the buyer, often utilized in B2B contexts or straightforward retail sales.[2, 10] Conversely, multi-level marketing (MLM), also known as network marketing, introduces a secondary revenue stream: the recruitment and training of other distributors.[11, 14] In an MLM structure, a participant’s “downline” consists of the individuals they have recruited, and the participant earns a percentage of the volume generated by this team.[11, 15] This creates a tiered compensation system that has historically driven massive growth for industry giants like Amway and Herbalife.[12, 16]

Recent trends have seen the rise of “Direct Online Sales” and “Subscription-Based Sales,” where companies leverage digital platforms and recurring revenue models to bypass physical storefronts entirely.[2] These models prioritize convenience and consistency, ensuring a predictable revenue stream for the business while providing curated replenishment for the consumer.[2]

Historical Trajectory: From Peddlers to Digital Influencers

The evolution of direct selling is an ancient narrative, tracing back to merchants in Rome who traveled between towns to showcase their wares.[13] During the Middle Ages and the Renaissance, traveling peddlers carried exotic goods like spices and silks, using storytelling and demonstrations to captivate potential buyers in marketplaces and private homes.[13] This tradition laid the groundwork for the modern direct selling channel, which gained formal structure in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.[16, 17]

The mid-20th century marked the “Golden Age” of the party plan model, exemplified by the 1945 launch of Tupperware.[18] Earl Tupper’s plastic products required demonstration to explain the “Tupperware seal,” and the resulting party plan—refined by pioneers like Brownie Wise—became a cultural phenomenon and a blueprint for group-selling.[18] This era also saw the 1959 founding of Amway by Jay Van Andel and Richard DeVos, who transformed a Nutrilite distributorship into the world’s largest multi-level marketing organization.[16]

The 1970s and 1980s were periods of rapid global expansion and increasing regulatory scrutiny. The 1979 FTC ruling on Amway was a watershed moment, as it established that the MLM model was a legitimate business structure provided it included certain safeguards, such as retail sales requirements and buy-back policies for unsold inventory.[19] This legal foundation allowed the industry to flourish internationally, entering markets in Europe, Latin America, and eventually Asia.[6, 20]

Economic Indicators and Market Performance 2024-2025

By the end of 2024, the global direct selling channel showed significant signs of stabilization after consecutive declines in 2022 and 2023.[3] Analysts observe that the post-pandemic slump, which reflected a hypergrowth correction, has likely bottomed out.[3, 21] Global sales were essentially flat in 2024, with a marginal decline of only 0.05%, while the average market growth rate improved to 4.6% in 2024, up from -5.4% in 2022.[3]

Metric2022 Data2023 Data2024 Data (Est.)
Global Retail Sales$170.0 Billion$167.6 Billion$163.9 – $194.9 Billion.[3, 22, 23]
Sales Change %-5.4%0.7%-0.05% (Stabilized).[3]
Markets Showing Growth23%42%45%.[3]
Billion-Dollar Markets212121.[3]

The market size for direct selling reached approximately $194.89 billion in 2024 and is projected to grow to $264.86 billion by 2029 at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 6.4%.[22] This growth is largely driven by the increasing demand for e-commerce, the adoption of digital tools, and the rising consumer preference for sustainable and science-backed health solutions.[6, 22]

However, the industry faces external economic headwinds. In spring 2025, rapid escalations in U.S. tariffs and trade tensions significantly impacted the retail and wholesale sectors.[22] Higher duties on imported consumer goods, including electronics and apparel, have raised procurement costs for direct selling entities, forcing them to choose between increasing prices for consumers or absorbing financial losses.[22] This geopolitical friction contributed to a modest 0.2% reduction in the long-term growth forecast for the market.[22]

Regional Market Analysis: Hotspots and Economic Drivers

Direct selling performance varies drastically by region, reflecting local economic needs and cultural attitudes toward entrepreneurship.

  • North America: The U.S. remains a critical hub, generating $34.7 billion in retail sales in 2024 through 5.4 million independent entrepreneurs.[21] Despite a general decline in revenue following pandemic highs, the perception of direct selling in the U.S. has improved, with 70% of consumers feeling positive about supporting local business owners like direct sellers.[21]
  • Asia Pacific: This region accounts for roughly 40% of the global direct sales market.[23] Markets such as India and Malaysia have seen continued expansion in wellness-based MLM sectors, driven by heightened post-pandemic health concerns.[6]
  • Latin America: Markets like Brazil ($8.0B) and Mexico ($6.87B) have shown growth, where high unemployment and inflation often drive individuals toward direct selling as a primary income source.[6]
  • Europe: With 14 million participants, Europe remains a mature market, though growth has stabilized.[23] Regulatory compliance with the GDPR and EU consumer directives remains a primary operational focus for firms in this territory.[24, 25]

Corporate Ecosystem: Leading Entities and Performance Data

The industry is dominated by several legacy giants that have sustained their positions through decades of market shifts, alongside newer, technology-integrated players.

Company2024 Revenue (Est. Billions USD)Focus Category
Amway$7.4Nutrition, Beauty, Home.[26]
Herbalife Nutrition$5.0Weight Management, Fitness.[27]
eXp Realty$4.5Real Estate Brokerage.[28]
Natura & Co$4.2Cosmetics, Sustainable Beauty.[28]
Vorwerk$3.4 (2023 data)Kitchenware, Appliances.[29]
Mary Kay$2.4Skin Care, Color Cosmetics.[30]
Nu Skin Enterprises$1.7Anti-aging, IoT Devices.[31]

Amway continues to hold the position of the world’s largest direct selling company, reporting $7.4 billion in sales for the year ending December 31, 2024.[26] While this represented a 3% decline from 2023—largely due to a strong U.S. dollar—the company’s nutrition category, led by the Nutrilite brand, grew to represent 64% of total global sales.[26] In late 2024, Michael Nelson assumed the role of CEO, bringing a focus on strategic investments in wellness and digital transformation.[26]

Herbalife reported net sales of $5.0 billion in 2024, showing a stabilization of revenue after internal initiatives like the “Herbalife Premier League” were launched to elevate distributor training and support.[27] The company’s weight management products account for 55.4% of its net sales.[32] Similarly, Natura & Co, a Brazilian giant, remains a leader in ethical beauty, while eXp Realty has demonstrated the power of the direct sales model within the professional services sector.[28, 29]

The Digital Transformation of 2025: Social Selling and AI

The most profound shift in the direct selling landscape is the move toward a “digital-first” sales model.[5] By 2025, 80% of B2B sales interactions are expected to occur via digital channels, and a significant portion of B2C transactions in the direct sales space will be facilitated through social media.[5, 8] This “Social Selling” pivot allows representatives to act as influencers, leveraging their personal brands to reach hundreds of customers simultaneously rather than through one-on-one interactions.[6]

The Impact of S-Commerce and Hybrid Models

Social commerce (S-commerce) integrates reviews, referrals, and ratings directly into the purchasing path.[8] This has given rise to the “hybrid affiliate+MLM” model, which simplifies compensation to emphasize sales commissions over recruitment.[6] This model attracts influencers and casual sellers who may not want to build a traditional downline but are interested in monetizing their digital reach.[5, 6]

Technological advancements have also facilitated “micro-fulfillment” infrastructure. In markets like Manila or Lagos, a direct seller can host a Facebook Live session, receive orders in real-time, and have the products delivered from a local warehouse the next day without ever touching the inventory.[6] This “asset-light” approach dramatically scales the potential of the individual distributor.[6]

AI and Automation in Direct Sales

In 2025, AI-assisted selling has moved from a novelty to a strategic necessity.[5] Sales teams using AI have reported a 50% increase in lead volume and a 60% reduction in call times.[5] Direct selling entities are increasingly deploying AI chat agents to enhance customer engagement and streamline lead qualification based on individual preferences.[5, 22]

Tool CategoryExample Tools (2025)Core Utility in Direct Sales
Social OutreachTaplio, LinkedIn Sales Navigator, Prosp.[33, 34, 35]Automating prospect identification and engagement.
Content CreationCanva Magic Studio, Jasper, Claude.[33, 35]Generating AI-driven marketing materials and carousels.
CRM & AutomationHubSpot Sales Hub, Salesforce Social Studio.[34, 35]Unified management of leads and social listening.
Salesforce SupportRallyware, Penny, Infinite MLM Software.[36]Gamified training, commission tracking, and genealogy.

The use of LinkedIn Sales Navigator is particularly critical for B2B direct sales professionals, providing metrics on industrial trending topics and discussions.[37] Meanwhile, platforms like Rallyware use gamification to improve distributor engagement and retention by providing personalized pathways to success.[36]

Regulatory Scrutiny: The FTC and Global Oversight

The direct sales industry, particularly the multi-level marketing (MLM) segment, operates under significant regulatory tension.[11, 14] The primary concern for regulators is the distinction between a legitimate product-based business and an illegal pyramid scheme.[14, 19] A pyramid scheme is generally defined as an organization where participants’ income is derived primarily from the recruitment of others rather than the sale of products to external retail customers.[14, 38]

The FTC’s 2025 Earnings Claim Rule

On January 13, 2025, the FTC announced a major regulatory shift by proposing the new “Earnings Claim Rule Regarding Multi-Level Marketing”.[4, 39] This proposed rule aims to curb deceptive earnings claims in the MLM industry by:

  • Mandating Substantiation: Prohibiting companies from making any earnings claims without having written substantiation (a “reasonable basis”) for those claims.[40]
  • Transparency in Language: Requiring that companies provide substantiation to anyone upon request, in the same language in which the claim was made.[39, 41]
  • Targeting “Lifestyle Claims”: Expanding enforcement against “lifestyle claims”—images of houses, luxury vacations, or cars that imply a level of wealth that is not typical for the average participant.[19, 42]
  • Civil Penalties: Allowing the FTC to seek civil penalties and redress for consumers from companies that make deceptive claims.[4]

The FTC notes that deceptive earnings claims are a “pervasive problem” in the industry, luring individuals with promises of financial freedom that rarely materialize.[4, 41] Furthermore, the Commission is exploring whether to mandate a “waiting period” before a new recruit can pay any money to join an MLM.[4]

International Compliance Standards

Globally, the regulatory environment ranges from supportive monitoring to total bans on MLM structures.

  • China: The Chinese government has a complex history with direct selling. In 1998, it instituted a ban on all direct sales, which was lifted in 2005 with the “Regulation of Direct Sales and Regulation on Prohibition of Chuanxiao” (MLM).[20, 43] Direct sales is legal under strict conditions: companies must have a license, can only pay out a single level of commission, and that commission is capped at 30%.[20, 44, 45] Multi-level marketing remains strictly illegal, though some companies operate in a “gray area” by using addresses in Taiwan or Hong Kong for their distributors.[20, 43]
  • India: The Consumer Protection (Direct Selling) Rules, 2021, have established a robust monitoring mechanism. Every direct selling entity must have a registered office in India, maintain a functional website with transparent product information, and appoint a “grievance redressal officer”.[46, 47] India also strictly prohibits pyramid schemes and “money circulation schemes”.[46, 48]
  • European Union: EU legislation, specifically Directive 2005/29/EC, blacklists pyramid promotional schemes.[25, 38] Member states such as Germany and Austria have even stricter requirements regarding “double opt-in” mechanisms for direct marketing to ensure consumer consent.[24]

Participant Economics: The Earnings Disparity and the 99% Debate

One of the most controversial aspects of the direct sales model, specifically in MLMs, is the success rate for individual participants. Consumer advocates frequently point to “abysmal statistics” showing that the vast majority of distributors do not make a profit.[49, 50]

Income Disclosure Analysis

Analysis of 2024 and 2025 income disclosures from major firms confirms a highly skewed earnings distribution.

Company / Participant TierAverage Annual Earnings% of Salesforce in Tier
Amway US (All IBOs)$723 (Before expenses)100%.[51]
Amway US (Founders Platinum)$46,4230.54%.[51]
Amway US (Top 10%)$14,251 (Average)10%.[51]
Herbalife US (Top 1%)$236,148+ (Est. from top 445)1%.[52]
Herbalife US (Median)~$3,216 (Est. from monthly)~50% (of those earning).[52]
Mary Kay Canada (Typical)$0 (No commission/bonus)>50%.[53, 54]
Mary Kay Canada (Eligible)$211 (Average)12.7%.[53, 54]

A study of 350 MLM companies in the United States suggested that at least 99% of recruits lose money.[11, 49] Many participants are “casual earners” who join primarily to receive a discount on products for personal use.[52, 55] For instance, Herbalife reports that the majority of its distributors in 2024 joined solely to receive a discount and did not sell products or recruit others.[52] However, critics argue that the “business opportunity” is often promoted as a path to “financial freedom,” creating a gap between expectation and reality.[42, 56]

The Gig Economy: A Rival and a Threat

The advent of app-based gig work, such as Uber or Instacart, represents an “existential threat” to the direct selling model.[7] While direct selling offers the lure of “being your own boss,” it lacks the immediate income guarantee found in the platform economy.[7, 57] An Uber driver knows they will be paid upon completion of a ride, whereas a direct seller may work for months without generating a commission.[7]

FeatureDirect Sales (MLM)Gig Economy (Uber/Lyft)
Start-up Costs$30 to $200 (Kits/Fees).[58]Generally free (requires car/phone).[7, 57]
Payment SpeedOften monthly; requires volume.[7]Often instant or weekly.[7, 59]
Work IndependenceHigh (Self-motivated).[9]High (Algorithm-driven).[57]
CommunityHigh (Conventions/Teams).[7, 11]Low (Isolated).[59]

The gig economy has shifted consumer and worker expectations toward “simplicity over complexity”.[60] Direct sellers are responding by attempting to reduce barriers to entry, such as eliminating sign-up fees and upgrading to “one-click” enrollment.[7] They are also focusing on “soft rewards”—adventure, fulfilment, and a sense of belonging—that algorithmic gig work cannot match.[7]

Sociological and Demographic Dimensions

Direct selling has historically provided an important economic outlet for women, who still constitute over 70% of the global salesforce.[3, 23] The industry has been described as an “unwinnable lottery” for many, yet it remains attractive to mothers seeking work-from-home opportunities and individuals from minority communities looking for community-based support.[50, 61]

The use of “neoliberal and feminist rhetoric” in recruitment is a hallmark of the industry, often framing product sales as “empowering” women or helping them “achieve financial independence”.[56, 61] During the COVID-19 pandemic, enrollment in MLMs skyrocketed as millions sought remote income sources.[50] However, legal scholars argue that the structure of these companies often leads to “social and financial harm,” as participants exploit their personal relationships (friends and family) to drive sales and recruitment.[11, 61]

The gender breakdown has shown a slight shift, with the share of women in the global sales force dipping from 74.3% in 2020 to 72.1% in 2024.[3] This shift is not yet fully understood but may reflect the rising involvement of men in digital social selling and the diversification of product categories into sectors like utilities and technology.[3, 6]

Ethics and Best Practices: The Industry’s Self-Correction

To counter the negative reputation associated with pyramid schemes, legitimate direct selling companies adhere to rigorous codes of ethics. The US Direct Selling Association (DSA) Code of Ethics, established in 1970, sets stringent guidelines for earnings representations, product claims, and return policies.[62, 63]

  • Buy-Back Policies: Member companies are required to offer a 90% refund on currently marketable materials within 12 months of purchase.[64] This “inventory buy-back” is a critical safeguard against “inventory loading,” where distributors are pressured to buy more product than they can sell just to stay active or qualify for bonuses.[14, 64]
  • Retail Sale Requirements: Companies like Amway and Herbalife mandate that a specific percentage of volume come from sales to external customers rather than internal consumption by the salesforce.[51, 52]
  • Compliance Certification: The DSA now offers a “Direct Selling Compliance Professional (DSCP) Certification,” which equips legal and marketing teams with the knowledge to create successful compliance programs based on current regulatory guidance.[65, 66]

Operational Logistics: Fulfillment and Inventory

In 2025, the operational burden of direct selling has shifted from the distributor to the corporate entity. Historically, distributors often kept significant “at-home” inventory to facilitate immediate sales.[1] Today, most major companies recommend an “inventory-free” approach, where the company handles the shipping and logistics directly once a sale is made through a representative’s personal website.[36, 58]

The industry is also seeing a rise in “Smarketing”—the alignment of sales and marketing departments to create a unified pipeline.[5] By combining marketing data with direct sales efforts, companies can achieve 36% higher customer retention and 38% higher sales win rates.[5] Furthermore, the use of outsourced sales teams for prospecting and lead generation has become a common way for companies to scale without the overhead of full-time staff.[5]

Conclusion: The Strategic Outlook for 2025 and Beyond

The direct sales industry in 2025 is a complex amalgam of ancient personal-contact traditions and cutting-edge digital intelligence.[13, 22] While the sector has stabilized post-pandemic, it remains under the microscope of regulators who are no longer satisfied with vague income disclosures.[3, 39] The success of the “zero-channel” model in the coming years will depend on its ability to distance itself from the “pyramid” moniker while embracing the efficiencies of AI and S-commerce.[5, 6]

The industry’s future appears to lie in the “hybrid affiliate” model, which combines the legal safety of single-level sales with the motivational power of network marketing.[6] For participants, the competition with the gig economy remains fierce, and firms must continue to innovate their “message” to emphasize the soft rewards of connection and personal growth.[7, 60] For the corporate sector, the challenge is one of transparency; as the FTC’s new earnings claim rule approaches finalization, the era of unsubstantiated “lifestyle” marketing is rapidly drawing to a close.[4, 41]

Ultimately, direct selling remains a vital economic engine, generating billions of dollars in revenue and providing millions of individuals with a flexible, low-risk path to entrepreneurship.[5, 21] Whether it can navigate the dual pressures of technological disruption and regulatory intervention will determine its position in the global retail hierarchy of the 2030s.

——————————————————————————–

  1. What exactly is direct selling? | A direct sales explainer – Zendesk, https://www.zendesk.com/blog/direct-selling/
  2. What Is Direct Sales? Types, Pros, & Cons, https://www.salesfocusinc.com/direct-sales/
  3. WFDSA STATS 2025, https://wfdsa.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/WFDSA-STATS-Report-2024-2025-V1.pdf
  4. FTC Proposes Rule Changes and New Rule to Deter Deceptive Earnings Claims by Multilevel Marketers and Money-Making Opportunity Sellers, https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2025/01/ftc-proposes-rule-changes-new-rule-deter-deceptive-earnings-claims-multilevel-marketers-money-making
  5. Direct Sales in 2025: 7 Trends and AI Strategies for B2B Sales Leaders – Martal Group, https://martal.ca/direct-sales-lb/
  6. Global direct selling in 2025: Growth hotspots in a shifting $167 billion market, https://www.epixelmlmsoftware.com/blog/global-direct-selling-growth-hotspots
  7. Can Direct Selling Survive the Gig Economy? – Momentum Factor, https://momofactor.com/dev/can-direct-selling-survive-the-gig-economy/
  8. New Trends in E-Commerce Research: Linking Social Commerce and Sharing Commerce: A Systematic Literature Review – MDPI, https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/14/23/16024
  9. What Is Direct Sales? Key Concepts and Benefits – Bardeen, https://www.bardeen.ai/answers/what-is-direct-sales
  10. How to Apply the Direct Sales Model to Maximize Revenue Opportunities – QuotaPath, https://www.quotapath.com/blog/direct-sales-model/
  11. Multi-level marketing – Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multi-level_marketing
  12. MLM vs. Network Marketing: Understanding the Key Differences | MLM vs. Network Marketing – Which One is Right for You? | Multi-Level Marketing vs. Network Marketing: Pros & Cons Explained | MLM vs. Network Marketing: How They Work & Which is More Profitable? | The Truth About MLM & Network Marketing – – Letscms, https://www.letscms.com/blog/mlm-vs-network-marketing-key-differences-which-one-is-best-for-you
  13. The Direct Selling Business Model Explained: A Complete and Comprehensive Overview, https://www.untaylored.com/post/the-direct-selling-business-model-explained-a-comprehensive-overview
  14. Multi-Level Marketing Businesses and Pyramid Schemes – Federal Trade Commission, https://consumer.ftc.gov/articles/multi-level-marketing-businesses-and-pyramid-schemes
  15. MLM vs SLM: Understanding the Differences – Network Marketing, https://networkmarketing.my/mlm-vs-slm/
  16. Amway – Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amway
  17. History, https://website4339296.nicepage.io/History.html
  18. MLM: A Brief History of Network Marketing – MLMLegal.com, https://mlmlegal.com/MLM%20articles/mlm-9-cycles-5.htm
  19. Business Guidance Concerning Multi-Level Marketing | Federal Trade Commission, https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/business-guidance-concerning-multi-level-marketing
  20. What’s going on in China? – MLM.com, https://www.mlm.com/whats-going-on-in-china/
  21. US Direct Selling Association Releases 2025 Growth & Outlook Study 2024 Data Shows Steady Interest in Direct Selling, https://www.dsa.org/events/news/individual-press-release/us-direct-selling-association-releases-2025-growth-outlook-study-2024-data-shows-steady-interest-in-direct-selling
  22. Direct Selling Market Report 2025, Size, Share And Research, https://www.thebusinessresearchcompany.com/report/direct-selling-global-market-report
  23. TOP 20 HOME-BASED MARKETING NETWORKING STATISTICS 2025 – Amra & Elma, https://www.amraandelma.com/home-based-marketing-networking-statistics/
  24. Overview of the direct marketing rules in the EU – single opt-in, soft opt-in, and double opt-in mechanisms | Opinion | DataGuidance, https://www.dataguidance.com/opinion/eu-overview-direct-marketing-rules-eu-single-opt
  25. E-002079/2023 – European Parliament, https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/E-9-2023-002079-ASW_EN.pdf
  26. Amway reports sales of $7.4B for 2024, https://www.amwayglobal.com/newsroom/amway-reports-sales-of-7-4b-for-2024/
  27. To Our Shareholders – Herbalife Ltd., https://ir.herbalife.com/sec-filings/all-sec-filings/content/0001213900-25-022834/ea0230772-03.pdf
  28. The 500+ Largest Direct Sales Companies In The World 2025 – Business For Home, https://www.businessforhome.org/2025/02/the-500-largest-direct-sales-companies-in-the-world-2025/
  29. Top 100 MLM Companies in the World by Revenue 2025 Global List, https://infinitemlmsoftware.com/blog/top-100-mlm-companies-2019/
  30. Mary Kay top earners 2025 | Leaders of Mary Kay network marketing – Epixel MLM Software, https://www.epixelmlmsoftware.com/blog/mary-kay-top-earners-network-marketing
  31. Top 10 Direct Selling Companies in North America | 2025 – Expert Market Research, https://www.expertmarketresearch.com/blogs/top-direct-selling-companies-in-north-america
  32. 10-K – Herbalife Ltd., https://ir.herbalife.com/sec-filings/all-sec-filings/content/0000950170-25-023207/hlf-20241231.htm
  33. 11 Best Social Selling Tools for Sales Professionals (2025) – ColdIQ, https://coldiq.com/blog/social-selling-tools
  34. Top 10 Social Selling Tools in 2025: Features, Pros, Cons & Comparison – DevOps School, https://www.devopsschool.com/blog/top-10-social-selling-tools-in-2025-features-pros-cons-comparison/
  35. What are your go-to marketing tools in 2025? : r/AskMarketing – Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/AskMarketing/comments/1ohep9y/what_are_your_goto_marketing_tools_in_2025/
  36. Best Direct Sales Software Reviewed In 2025, https://infinitemlmsoftware.com/blog/best-direct-sales-softwares/
  37. Social Selling In 2025: The Ultimate Guide – The CMO, https://thecmo.com/demand-generation/social-media-sales/
  38. Avoid illegitimate schemes | Direct Selling Europe, https://directsellingeurope.eu/avoid-illegitimate-schemes
  39. Earnings Claim Rule: Notice of Proposed Rulemaking – Federal Trade Commission, https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/r111003earningclaimsnprm01132025.pdf
  40. Earnings Claim Rule Regarding Multi-Level Marketing – Federal Trade Commission, https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/federal-register-notices/earnings-claim-rule-regarding-multi-level-marketing
  41. Concerned about deceptive earnings claims? So’s the FTC, and we want your feedback, https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/blog/2025/01/concerned-about-deceptive-earnings-claims-sos-ftc-we-want-your-feedback
  42. FTC Continues to Target MLMs and Other “Money-Making Opportunity Sellers” – Federal Lawyer, https://federal-lawyer.com/ftc-continues-to-target-mlms-and-other-money-making-opportunity-sellers/
  43. China’s Multi-Level Marketing ban: a workaround? – VF Franchise Consulting, https://vffranchiseconsulting.com/chinas-multi-level-marketing-ban-workaround/
  44. MLM Laws In China – Wellman & Warren LLP | Business Litigation Law Firm, https://w-wlaw.com/mlm-laws-in-china/
  45. Multi-Level Marketing: China Isn’t Buying It – China Briefing News, https://www.china-briefing.com/news/multi-level-marketing-china-isnt-buying/
  46. UNDER RULE 102 (1) (Total Pages 1-12) – India Code, https://www.indiacode.nic.in/ViewFileUploaded?path=AC_HR_67_134_00008_00008_1751868825924/orderindividualfile/&file=direct_selling_mechanism_order_of_consumer_protection_act_2019.pdf
  47. Consumer Protection (Direct – Selling) Rules, 2021, https://thc.nic.in/Central%20Governmental%20Rules/Consumer%20Protection%20(Direct%20Selling)%20Rules,%202021.pdf
  48. India (Updated April 2025) – wfdsa, https://wfdsa.org/india/
  49. The Case (for and) against Multi-level Marketing – Federal Trade Commission, https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/public_comments/trade-regulation-rule-disclosure-requirements-and-prohibitions-concerning-business-opportunities-ftc.r511993-00017%C2%A0/00017-57317.pdf
  50. Regulating the Reluctant: Policies that Benefit Vulnerable People in Multi-Level Marketing, https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1267&context=jlasc
  51. Income Disclosure | Amway United States, https://www.amway.com/income-disclosure
  52. Key Information About Being an Herbalife Independent Distributor, https://www.herbalife.com/content/dam/global-reusable-assets/documents/pd-statement-typical-distributor-earnings-en-us.pdf
  53. canadian-statement-of-typical-participant-earnings-2024.pdf – Mary Kay, https://www.marykay.ca/-/media/images/mk/united-states/canada/esuite/footer/canadian-statement-of-typical-participant-earnings-2024.pdf
  54. EarningsPage Bilingual-8_5x11_2022_prepared2023_vf.indd, https://truthinadvertising.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/MaryKay_IncomeDisclosure_Canada_2022.pdf
  55. Association Guidelines, https://www.dsa.org/consumerprotection/association-guidelines
  56. The Ethical Implications of the Multi-Level Marketing Industry – ScholarWorks@UARK, https://scholarworks.uark.edu/context/mktguht/article/1080/viewcontent/Lauren_Longworth_thesis_final_draft___The_Ethical_Implications_of_the_Multi.pdf
  57. The Gig Economy: Shaping the Future of Work and Business | Park University, https://www.park.edu/blog/the-gig-economy-shaping-the-future-of-work-and-business/
  58. 15 Direct Sales Companies Perfect for Moms who want to Work from Home, https://startamomblog.com/direct-sales-companies/
  59. The Pros and Cons of the Gig Economy, https://www.wgu.edu/blog/pros-and-cons-gig-economy1808.html
  60. The Evolution of Direct Selling & Impact of the Gig Economy – afeusa, https://afeusa.org/articles/the-evolution-of-direct-selling-impact-of-the-gig-economy/
  61. Multilevel Marketing, an Unwinnable Lottery: How MLMs Illegally Target Women and Minorities Using Deceptive and Predatory Recrui – Georgetown Law, https://www.law.georgetown.edu/gender-journal/wp-content/uploads/sites/20/2023/04/GT-GJGL230006.pdf
  62. Code of Ethics – Direct Selling Association, https://www.dsa.org/docs/default-source/ethics/codeofethics-fulltext.pdf?sfvrsn=4
  63. DSA Code of Ethics – Direct Selling Education Foundation, https://dsef.org/what-we-do/ethics-initiative/dsa-code-of-ethics/
  64. Direct Selling Association’s Code of Ethics – The Standard for an Accountable Marketplace, https://www.dsa.org/docs/default-source/advocacy/code-of-ethics-factsheet.pdf?sfvrsn=0
  65. Direct Selling Compliance Certification Program: DSA, https://www.dsa.org/forms/meeting/MeetingFormPublic/view?id=69E68000000099
  66. Register Now for the DSA’s Direct Selling Compliance Professional (DSCP) Certification in April – Momentum Factor, https://momofactor.com/dev/2022-direct-selling-compliance-certification/

JOIN THIS RESEARCH Researcher I Business I Partner

Administrator
, , , ,

Leave a comment